IMAGINE, IF YOU CAN, (it’s difficult) that you had no sense of taste and everything had the flavor of potatoes mashed in tepid water. And because throat and nose are related you’d probably also lost your sense of smell (adosma), which could be dangerous if you weren’t able to detect gas leaks, smoke or decay. Complete loss of taste is known as augesia and partial as hypogeusia. Both frustratingly deprive you of the zestiness of delicacies as varied as marzipan cookies or spicy chicken curry.
“The taste buds can only detect sweet, sour, salty and bitter – the full symphony of flavor comes from the nose,” said Dr. Charles P. Kimmelman, a Manhattan anosmia specialist. “But when your brain is hit really hard, it wiggles like Jell-O, and the little fibers going from the smell nerve endings up to the brain are stretched taut. Some of them get torn, injured or bruised.”
Can the damaged fibers actually regenerate? “To a certain extent,” Dr. Kimmelman said. “But not necessarily along the same pathways they had before. It’s like a crossed circuit. And there’s usually a phantom sensation, like when a person loses a foot but still feels like his toe is hurting. The brain is trying to make sense of what little information it has coming in.”
Anosmia may be caused not only by head trauma but also by upper respiratory infection, nasal or sinus disease and exposure to toxins. Some people are born with the condition, Dr. K added, with many anosmia patients recovering only 20 to 30 percent of their sensory function , even if that.
The five taste sensations you’ll have lost (they also include umami, defined as “brothy, meaty, savory”) results in a boring diet, and only adding salt and pepper or some more piquant condiment gives a touch of minor substance to otherwise endlessly bland dishes. Without a sense of taste you are left merely with temperature and texture, and only memory helps to make whatever you’re eating worthwhile. Some stronger flavors such as blue cheese, anchovies, pepperoni pizza offer a hint of themselves, and ice cream remains delicious even if you can’t distinguish one kind from another. But, in general, if your smell and taste disappear you’re left bereft. Life has literally lost a lot of its flavor.
Sadly, this was my fate a few months ago—to recover from a severe and long-lasting cough only to discover that I could neither taste anything or smell anything. Naturally I found this state to be profoundly depressing, and my angst was not relieved when I discovered that (a) it’s not an uncommon affliction when you get older; and (b) usually there’s no cure.
Ordinary doctors often don’t have a clue about this and usually refer you to Ear, Nose and Throat specialists (known as ENT doctors) but even many of these are content to tell you that there’s nothing much you can do. The source, they say, is a virus which the dictionary defines as “the causative agent of an infectious disease” but which more generally seems to be regarded as “un-eradicable”.
Thus, what became to me instantly apparent, was how little medicine knew about this state and, if they did know, how rarely they were willing to share the information. My own doctor referred me (via my health plan) to an ENT Specialist who averred there was little could be done, even if expensive tests found a cause (unlikely, he emphasized). Neither a Medicare session with a doctor in Ventura, followed by a $20-a-minute session ($25) over the Internet with another in Santa Barbara, gave me any suggestion about how to restore my taste. “Wait it out; it may come back” was the verdict.
Unwilling to accept this depressing scenario—after all, the subject must have been thoroughly researched by now—I turned my attention to the professional body, the American Academy of Otorcaryngology to which most ENT doctors belong. As it happens they were having their annual meeting in San Francisco that month and, presenting myself as a professional reporter, I contacted them through their friendly PR department. After a series of e-mail exchanges I was given several contacts, among them Dr. Michael Hirsch in Chicago and Dr. Natasha Mirza at the University of Pennsylvania, both reputed to be experts. Both declined to answer my questions unless I flew across country to see them as a patient, an expensive proposition that I could not afford.
Next I was advised to find an ENT doctor at UCLA which my health provider wouldn’t approve, although they offered a private appointment—with no promise about results—for a mere $800. I also declined this.
There were several questions for which I sought answers:
- Is there any estimate of how many people lose their sense of taste/smell and what percentage of them regain it?
- Apart from age and such maladies as flu, severe coughs and colds etc what are the other causes of loss? Can it get worse and spread to other things?
- Why do so many doctors imply that they can give you something to cure diseases, infections etc, but viruses are beyond treatment? Could this be true?
- Is there any ‘cure’ for loss of taste and smell? anything one can take that might bring it back? or any lifestyle change or habits to adopt that might help?
None of the experts I had contacted would answer these questions and nor could I extract even so much as a courteous reply to either of my letters to Jane E. Brody whose Personal Health column in the New York Times has recently dealt with such subjects as calories, narcolepsy, IUDs and yoga. And so it was back to the Academy which this time referred me to Dr David Eibling, Chair Geriatric Committee of American Academy of Otolaryngology. He was more helpful.
“You are right”, he wrote, “there are relatively few ‘experts’ in this field….The differential diagnosis is lengthy, and more is unknown than is known. The first fork in the diagnosis is whether it is conductive (like hearing loss) or sensori-neural. Conductive hyposmia (or anosmia) is due to blockage of the airflow through the upper part of the nasal passages. A regular cold can do it, although nasal polyps are the most common cause of long term loss. This diagnosis is easily made by any otolaryngologist just by placing a scope into the nose and looking. Treatment is usually very effective in returning the sense of smell.
“Chronic infection can also be a cause - sometimes you can see with a scope, other times imaging, usually a CT scan is required. Again, treatment is effective. Most of the disorders are, unfortunately sensori-neural, and not likely to respond to treatment. Such loss can be caused by head trauma, severe infection, or some sort of neurodegenrative process.
“There is considerable recent interest in toxins, particularly zinc, the active ingredient of Zicam, a zinc-containing OTC preparation used to reduce the duration of a cold. The Zicam controversy went on for several years, but I think now the jury is voting that it can lead to hyposmia. Other rare causes include medications, especially some common meds such as ACE inhibitors such as lisinopril.”
There was one more stop in my quest (approved by my health plan via the helpful Ventura doctor Armin Alavi), an MRI scan – a curious experience resembling a 30-minute electronic concert that takes place after you have been slid recumbent into a narrow tunnel, head enclosed in a transparent plastic cover. Disappointingly, the MRI revealed nothing that took me any further, leaving me back where I began with no suggested cure or even helpful behavior. Six months later, I still have no sense of taste or smell. Happy to hear from anybody out there who knows anything more.
AMONG THE THINGS that I miss the most is my taste for chocolate, especially English brands to which I have been devoted since my long-ago childhood. Thus, I was intrigued by the information about the newly opened museum devoted to chocolate in York, the northern England town to which so many familiar brands owe their origin.
When the Quaker son of a grocer Joseph Rowntree (1830-1926) started making chocolate in York it was hardly a new industry. Joseph Fry’s Bristol company dated back to the 1760’s and John Cadbury started up in Birmingham the following century. Both companies merged in 1919 but the scions of both Fry’s and Cadbury’s apprenticed in York with Rowntree who had become a generous philanthropist offering his 4,000 employees free education, a library, help care and a pension fund.
The mid-19th century chocolate company of Joseph Terry remained in York until 2005 but a commercial development on the old site is still called The Chocolate Works. Six million Kit Kats are still churned out in York every day.
In 1969, Rowntree merged with another famous name, that of John Mackintosh, widely known as “the toffee king”. And despite the inevitable buyouts by humongous global companies—Rowntree and Terry by Nestle, Cadbury by Kraft—most of those delicious chocolate bars have retained their original names. Attendance has been growing steadily since the opening last month of the new museum where chocolate’s history (since the Aztecs) and manufacturing processes are displayed. And, of course, there are free samples.
Nestle: Kit Kat, Walnut Whip, Yorkie, Aero, Turkish Delight
Kraft: Flake, Crunchie, Crème Egg, Chocolate Cream, Chocolate Orange
this link to a friend
Sign-up to receive this column weekly by email
send a comment to John Wilcock
- Complete column archives:
2006 - present
— From the archives... The religion of Violence & Statistics, otherwise known as college football; WPA II; Would it be called Indiastan or Pakindia?; Who you Gonna call? Crime Predictors; Being a Bank means you never having to say you're sorry; Oil vs. Democracy, and of course, the Wilcock Web...
– Week of December 9, 2017
— From the archives... The Mother of All Family Feuds, Otaku Means Geek in Japanese, Affirmative Action or 'It all depends on who you know', The Moonies are packin', and of course, the Wilcock Web......
– Week of December 2, 2017
— Taxing land, not people, Is Socialism Scary?, Stars acting as assholes, Big Thinkers can be such Morons, and of course, The Wilcock Web...
– Week of November 18, 2017
— Dear Reader,
– Week of August 23, 2017
— Dear Readers...
– Week of January 25, 2017
— John Wilcock ... Marijuana, the symbolic center of the underground society
– Week of June 8, 2016
— John Wilcock ... From the Archives: Cuba Diary—Havana, April 2011
– Week of April 20, 2016
— John Wilcock ... Manhattan Memories: Chapter Nineteen (continued)--Travels
– Week of April 16, 2016
— John Wilcock ... From the Archives: When you vote, donâ€™t forget the Republican Paradox
– Week of April 13, 2016
— John Wilcock ... Manhattan Memories: Chapter Nineteen--Travels: Tokyo-Rick Kennedy recalls; Japan on $5 a Day; About Chapbooks; Magic in South America
– Week of April 9, 2016
— John Wilcock ... Manhattan Memories: Chapter Eighteen (continued)--Theory & Practice of Travel Writing;
Remoteness of Callanish;
Jim's Paris dinners
– Week of April 2, 2016
— John Wilcock ... Manhattan Memories: Chapter Eighteen--The Quest for Magic: Around Europe by VW bus;
Regarding armchair travelers;
Pisa's Leaning Tower;
The magical Alhambra
– Week of March 26, 2016
— John Wilcock ... Manhattan Memories: Chapter Seventeen (continued)--London's Magical library;
In the Cannes
– Week of March 19, 2016
— John Wilcock ... Manhattan Memories: Chapter Seventeen--The Sorcerer's Apprentice
– Week of March 12, 2016
— John Wilcock ... Manhattan Memories: Chapter Sixteen--JW'S Secret Diary (continued)
– Week of March 5, 2016
— John Wilcock ... Manhattan Memories: Chapter Sixteen--JW'S Secret Diary
– Week of February 27, 2016
— John Wilcock ... Manhattan Memories: Chapter Fourteen (Part Two--Manhattan phone book, JW'S Secret Diary
– Week of February 20, 2016
— John Wilcock ... Manhattan Memories: Chapter Fourteen--Party Circuit
– Week of February 13, 2016
— John Wilcock ... Manhattan Memories: Chapter Thirteen--Figaro Diary, part two, Soho Saturday
– Week of February 6, 2016
— John Wilcock ... Manhattan Memories: Chapter Thirteen--Figaro Diary, part one, Soho Saturday
– Week of January 30, 2016
— John Wilcock ... Manhattan Memories: Chapter Twelve (continued)--Traveling with Nomad; SoHo Confidential
– Week of January 23, 2016
— John-Wilcock ... Manhattan Memories: Chapter Twelve--Andy Gets Shot: Max's Kansas City;
Jane Fonda's gesture;
Christo & Jeanne-Claude
– Week of January 16, 2016
— John-Wilcock ... Manhattan Memories: Chapter Eleven (continued)-- We go to Rutgers, Ann Arbor ...
What people say about Andy
– Week of January 9, 2016
— John-Wilcock ... Manhattan Memories: Chapter Eleven -- Andy Warhol First encounter....People talk about him....His movies...
– Week of January 2, 2016
— John-Wilcock ... Manhattan Memories: Chapter Chapter Ten (continued)--The 'Movement' splits: Eldridge Cleaver
Year of the Great Hoaxâ€¦The OZ trial
– Week of December 26, 2015
— John-Wilcock ... Manhattan Memories: Chapter Chapter Ten--Tom Forcade's smuggling funds High Times;
Rolling Stone's underground sabotage
– Week of December 19, 2015
— John-Wilcock ... Manhattan Memories: Chapter Chapter Nine (continued)--Rip Torn on stardom… Robert Mitchum's gift; London: Julian Beck’s critique; Emmett Grogan and the Diggers; Greece: The Junta, Charlotte Rampling, and art hero Daniel Spoerri
– Week of December 12, 2015
— John-Wilcock ... Manhattan Memories: Chapter Chapter Nine--Bob Dylan in the Village, Abbie Hoffman and Jerry Rubin, Richard Neville and OZ, What Does London Need Most?, The International Times
– Week of December 5, 2015
— John-Wilcock ... Manhattan Memories: Chapter Eight (continued)--Japan: a working honeymoon;
The Shinjuku Sutra
– Week of November 28, 2015
— John-Wilcock ... Manhattan Memories: Chapter Eight--Art Kunkin's LA Free Press; In LA with Hunter Thompson, Lenny Bruce; Visit by Warhol; Hakim Jamal plays god; The San Francisco 'Be-In'; Underground papers meet
– Week of November 21, 2015
— John-Wilcock ... Manhattan Memories: Chapter Seven (continued)--The Underground Press; Army revolt: Â fragging officers; Bowart goes to Millbrook
– Week of November 14, 2015
— Manhattan Memories: Chapter Seven--The singing Tit-o-Gram; The East Village Other; Art & Forgery; Birth of Black Power; The Underground Press
– Week of November 7, 2015
— Manhattan Memories: Chapter Six (continued)--Tom Forcade: smuggler supreme; That pathetic drug czar
– Week of October 31, 2015
— Manhattan Memories: Chapter Sixâ€”The weed that changed the world--Confessions of a pot smoker
– Week of October 24, 2015
— Manhattan Memories: Chapter Fiveâ€”Reefer Madness (continued)--Jan and Stan change my life; The man who turned on the world
– Week of October 17, 2015
— Manhattan Memories: Chapter Fiveâ€”Reefer Madness--The man who turned on the world; Tested by Harvard professors; Jan and Stan change my life
– Week of October 10, 2015
— Manhattan Memories: Chapter Fourâ€”Into the '60s--London's underground press; Jean-Jacques Lebel burns US flag; Everybody's friend: Jim Haynes; Lenny Bruce and the kitchen tapes
– Week of October 3, 2015
— Manhattan Memories: Chapter Fourâ€”Into the '60s--More Working at The New York Times; Mexico On $5 a Day; What Richard Condon taught me; Henry Miller's wise words
– Week of September 26, 2015
— Manhattan Memories: Chapter Three--The Village Voice (continued) --Lasting insignificance: the 3-dot column, ECHOÂ and Larry Adler, Woody Allen plays classic nerd, A sample Village Square column
– Week of September 19, 2015
— Manhattan Memories: Chapter Three--More trouble with our star novelist; Lasting insignificance: the 3-dot column; Jean Shepherdâ€™s phantom novel
– Week of September 12, 2015
— Manhattan Memories: Chapter Two--Steve Allen derides TV columnist; Marlene Dietrich--glamorous grandmother
– Week of September 5, 2015
— Manhattan Memories: Chapter Two--Gilbert Seldes' The Lively Arts; Norman Mailerâ€™s Voice column; Giving parties to meet strangers
– Week of August 29, 2015
— Manhattan Memories: Chapter One--Chatting with Marilyn Monroe
– Week of August 22, 2015
— Manhattan Memories: Chapter One--Jack Kent Cooke tells me to stay in Canada; Becoming a New Yorker ;A new Village newspaper; The casual wisdom of Steve Allen
– Week of August 15, 2015
— Manhattan Memories: Introduction.
– Week of August 8, 2015
- column archives:
2006 - present
in the press...
Wednesday, October 27, 2010
A Budget Travel Pioneer on a Time When $5 a Day Was Real (Frugal) Money
nytimes.com: Frugal Traveler
by Seth Kugel
It was the first handwritten letter I’d received in 5 years. Or maybe 10. Signed by John Wilcock, a man I’d never heard of, and postmarked Ojai, Calif., it was waiting for me when I returned from my São Paulo-to-New York summer trip. Mr. Wilcock wrote that he had been an assistant editor at The Times Travel section back in the 1950s, and had written the first editions of “Mexico on $5 a Day,” “Greece on $5 a Day” and “Japan on $5 a Day” for Arthur Frommer in the 1960s.
By George, I thought. This man was the original Frugal Traveler.
by John Wilcock
"A GOOD WAY to describe John Wilcock is to say that he is a talented bohemian counter-culture journalist who once played a major role in the emergence of America’s underground press. Born 1927 in Sheffield, England, he left school aged 16 to work on various newspapers in England, and on Toronto periodicals before moving to New York City. There in 1955 he became one of the five founders of the Village Voice in which he and co-founder Norman Mailer wrote weekly columns. Wilcock called his column “The Village Square”, an intended pun. He and young Mailer were not quite friends, although Wilcock was at times annoyed, but always amused, by Mailer’s monstrous ego."
-From the preface of Manhattan Memories, by Martin Gardner
The Autobiography and Sex Life of Andy Warhol
by John Wilcock
Edited by Christopher Trela
Photographs by Shunk-Kender
Village Voice and Interview cofounder John Wilcock was first drawn into the
milieu of Andy Warhol through film-maker Jonas Mekas, assisting on some
of Warhol’s early films, hanging out at his parties and quickly becoming a
regular at the Factory. “About six months after I started hanging out at the
old, silvery Factory on West 47th Street,” he recalls, “[Gerard] Malanga came
up to me and asked, ‘When are you going to write something about us?’”
Already fascinated by Warhol’s persona, Wilcock went to work, interviewing
the artist’s closest associates, supporters and superstars. Among these were
Malanga, Naomi Levine, Taylor Mead and Ultra Violet, all of whom had been
in the earliest films; scriptwriter Ronnie Tavel, and photographer Gretchen
Berg; art dealers Sam Green, Ivan Karp, Eleanor Ward and Leo Castelli, and
the Metropolitan Museum of Art’s Henry Geldzahler; the poets Charles Henri
Ford and Taylor Mead, and the artist Marisol; and the musicians Lou Reed and Nico. Paul Morrisey supplied the title: The Autobiography and Sex Life of
Andy Warhol was the first oral biography of the artist. First published in 1971,
and pitched against the colorful backdrop of the 1960s, it assembles a prismatic
portrait of one of modern art’s least knowable artists during the early
years of his fame. The Autobiography and Sex Life is likely the most revealing
portrait of Warhol, being composite instead of singular; each of its interviewees
offers a piece of the puzzle that was Andy Warhol. This new edition
corrects the many errors of the first, and is beautifully designed in a bright,
Warholian palette with numerous illustrations.
The British-born writer John Wilcock co-founded The Village Voice in 1955,
and went on to edit seminal publications such as The East Village Other, Los
Angeles Free Press, Other Scenes and (in 1970) Interview, with Andy Warhol.